Babyccinos and Reel Making: Who is Really Playing?

Photo by Juliia Abramova
A children’s menu, a play kitchen, a coloring book: Is that what makes a space #kidsproof? Laura Vermeeren explores how Instagram’s aestheticized content increasingly shapes what family leisure in the city should look like.
[Ed. note: This article is part of a dossier on Playable Cities.]

I have a free afternoon and am walking in the city of Utrecht, the Netherlands, with my three-year-old. We have been up early, I need a coffee and my child needs a clean nappy and something to eat, which I stupidly forgot to pack. Into a cafe we run: a lovely place with hipster vibes – green plants, local art, tattooed baristas, and friendly smiles. I walk in and rush to the toilets: more tasteful art on the walls, but no space to change a nappy. I manage, awkwardly, changing her standing up and dump the nappy in the tiny open bin that was clearly not meant for something so stinky. We emerge flustered and hungry, only to find that in this carefully curated space, children and their parents were never part of the design. No high chair, no real food for little ones, and the friendly smiles do not extend to a toddler when I ask for anything to eat for her. Sitting down with my coffee, I take a breath and wonder why something as simple as a peanut butter sandwich is not on the menu. It feels like a quiet but deliberate exclusion. As I reflected on the design choices around me that assume a default user – adult but child-free, able-bodied, hip – I wondered how much the city around us is set up in the same way. Urban life, how we dwell, and what we choose to do in the city are inherently shaped by its urban design, this much is obvious. But how is the child, and the child’s play written into this blueprint today? The right to play has been understood as a fundamental right by the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, and in 2024, the first ever International Day of Play was held, which affirmed the importance of play:

It … fosters resilience, creativity, and innovation in individuals. For children in particular, play helps build relationships and improves control, overcome trauma, and problem-solving. It helps children develop the cognitive, physical, creative, social, and emotional skills they need to thrive in a rapidly changing world.1“International Day of Play,” United Nations, accessed July 15, 2025, https://www.un.org/en/observances/international-day-of-play.

Play is also, according to the UN, positively impacting “tolerance, resilience, and facilitating social inclusion, conflict prevention, and peacebuilding.”2“International Day of Play,” United Nations, accessed July 15, 2025, https://www.un.org/en/observances/international-day-of-play. The assumption here is, I would think, that children play together in some form to reap all of these benefits. Free and independent play in public spaces is beneficial for the development of civil society and hence, for democracy.3Roger Hart, “Containing Children: Some Lessons on Planning for Play from New York City,” Environment and Urbanization 14, no. 2 (2002): 135–48.

@explore_utrecht_kids. Screenshot of Instagram post, February 4, 2025, screenshot in author’s collection. Translation: “Discover this newly opened kidsproof pearl in the Utrecht area. Child menu ✔ Play kitchen ✔ Coloring page ✔”.

As much as 60 percent of the world’s children will live in cities by the year 2025, as estimated by the UN. We see their right to play reflected in urban design policy, although children are rarely the focus of urban designers.4Tim Gill, Urban Playground: How Child-Friendly Planning and Design Can Save Cities (RIBA Publishing, 2021). No longer do only the Floridian footloose creative classes of the nineties flock to the city, but increasingly families as well. This means that the everyday lives of uncountable children are actively shaped by how the urban environment around them is shaped, and what kind of spaces are written into this environment that allow for moments of play.5Willem R. Boterman, Residential Practices of Middle Classes in the Field of Parenthood (University of Amsterdam, 2012). The first thing that comes to mind, for me at least, when we consider the nexus children/cities/play, are playgrounds. But historically, the child in the city played everywhere and, argues Tim Gill, enjoyed high levels of freedom playing games on the streets and sidewalks, in parks and undeveloped green spaces. However, Gill observes, “fast-forward a couple of generations to the children of today, and their horizons have shrunk almost to within the shadows cast by their homes.”6Gill, Urban Playground, 4. The sight of children playing in the street is indeed slowly disappearing – a direct result of car-centered urban planning resulting in unhealthy fumes and traffic accidents.7Katherine L. Frohlich and Patricia A. Collins, “Children’s Right to the City and Their Independent Mobility: Why It Matters for Public Health,”  Epidemiol Community Health  78 (2024): 66–68; Roger Hart, “Containing Children: Some Lessons on Planning for Play from New York City,” Environment and Urbanization 14, no. 2 (2002): 135–48. This “motonormativity,” as per Katherine Frohlich and Patricia Collins, has strengthened the idea that “streets exist simply for the movement and storage of motorized vehicles and has effectively displaced children (and other non- motorists) from our cities’ most ample public spaces – streets.”8Frohlich and Collins, “Children’s Right to the City and Their Independent Mobility,” 66. As the city became increasingly developed and ordered, the cracks in which chaotic, messy and creative play for children, and perhaps even their parents who would sit on the curb and watch their children play while chatting to neighbors, was still available, disappeared. In its place, designated play areas have been set up, a prime example of “ludic architecture”: safe, controlled and often supervised environments where children can engage in physical, imaginative, and social play.

The picture I just painted appears rather bleak: a city that has steadily tucked unrestricted and creative play away and redesigned it in designated corners where play is controlled. But cities have historically been seen as prime centers of fun, joy and entertainment.9Michiel E. De Lange, “The Playful City: Using Play and Games to Foster Citizen Participation,” in Social Technologies and Collective Intelligence, ed. Aelita Skaržauskienė (Mykolas Romeris University, 2015), 428. What forms of play and playing, then, are possible, are desired and are designed in the city? And, who gets to play, where, and under what conditions? While my daughter started stacking the sugar sachets and tearing up napkins – a tiny makeshift act of spatial subversion that turned the marble café table into a construction site and creating a brief moment of play where none was planned or designed, I opened my Instagram to check which café I should have gone to with my child in this area so she could have had a proper nappy change, and I would have had a more peaceful coffee moment. On Instagram we find moms, mostly, who go through the effort of mapping the city for their followers by selecting, reviewing and visually documenting the best “kids proof” locations – restaurants, cafes, museums and playgrounds – throughout the city. They go out and might be the ones who are really playing here: crafting attractive reels with laughing children and steaming cappuccinos, providing honest reviews and taking stock of all the child-friendly features of the place. Through these practices, parents participate in a form of digital placemaking, making the city their own, and enacting what Michel de Certeau would call “spatial stories”10Michel de Certeau, “Spatial Stories,” in The Practice of Everyday Life, trans. Steven Rendall (University of California Press, 1984), 115–130. – a production of urban space through everyday practices. Digital media now by and large govern our everyday practices, and how we make sense of urban environments and the social production of a place. Through these everyday interactions with online platforms we help transform often-overwhelming urban spaces into meaningful environments. These places then become something else: they feel lived-in, recognizable, and personal and allow people to humanize the city, even amidst complex dynamics.11Germaine R. Halegoua, The Digital City: Media and the Social Production of Place (NYU Press, 2020). This perspective highlights how digital media are not just tools for navigation or documentation, but central to how urban space is emotionally inhabited. A user-generated map that identifies all the places where children are actively welcomed and accommodated for is such a meaningful act of digital placemaking and belonging. Where I felt out of place in the hipster café, these Instagram moms are actively helping me and other parents to reframe and rethink the urban landscape as a place with pockets of child- (and thus parent-)friendly spaces.

But critical sidenotes are easy to make here. The idea of owning the city seems less empowering considering that the unpaid digital labor of mothers – geotagging, visual documentation, captioning and the surprisingly laborious work of editing reels – becomes part of Instagram’s ecosystem, enriching the platform’s data economy. So while parents drink their coffee warm and are reclaiming the city for their families, they are also producing value for Mark Zuckerberg, the man who successfully persuaded the White House last year to postpone legislation that would have required Instagram to implement changes aimed at protecting children from bullying, sexual exploitation, and other online harms.12R. Reader, “Zuckerberg’s Enlisting the GOP against Tech Rivals Apple and Google,” Politico, April 20, 2025, https://www.politico.com/news/2025/04/20/zuckerbergs-enlisting-the-gop-against-tech-rivals-apple-and-google-00295945. ‘Owning the city’ is perhaps empowering at the surface level but extractive underneath.

I have used a visual discourse analysis of Instagram posts tagged with #kidsproof in the Netherlands to understand how parents perform the idea of a “childproofed” city life.13I built my corpus by doing regular, manual searches of the hashtag #kidsproof on Instagram between November 2024 and March 2025. From this process, I selected 50 public posts tagged with #kidsproof, shared between 2022 and 2025 by 13 distinct individual users. Posts were sampled to represent urban contexts: cafés, museums, and restaurants. This hashtag is widely used in the Dutch language to signal locations and activities considered suitable for children, often by parents sharing their recommendations or experiences with their followers, other parents. I focus on individual accounts – especially those that share visual and textual representations of family outings, leisure, or daily life in the city. Apart from practical reasons of data collection, the reason for choosing the hashtag #kidsproof was because of a tension that I felt in the word itself, that reflects and builds upon the larger concerns of this article on who is, actually, playing in the city. To “proof” something, is to treat it as vulnerable to damage from an outside danger, e.g waterproof, foolproof, shockproof – all imply resistance, protection, or exclusion. A childproof space, I theorize, does not include the child as a subject, but actively guards against that child as a source of chaos and disorder. Its protective tools, I suggest, are coloring books, babyccinos and the infamous IKEA play kitchen tucked away in a designated corner.

Instagrammable play

One useful way to think about Instagram’s relationship to urban space is offered by John Boy and Justus Uitermark, who think of the platform as a “membrane over the surface of the city.”14John D. Boy and Justus Uitermark, “Reassembling the City through Instagram,” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 42 (2017): 613. Instagram, they argue, makes visible only certain parts of the urban landscape – usually the glamorous, the hip, the refined – and passes them through to users. Mothers who are mapping the city for childproof places do something similar. By following a handful of these accounts, a new city appears in front of our eyes. We suddenly know which restaurant has a changing mat and which café was thoughtful enough to add child-friendly food to their menu. This Google Maps screenshot covered in icons representing cafés with play spaces across the Netherlands, made by a mother on Instagram, reveals how the city is being digitally reterritorialized through #kidsproof labor. Each icon is the result of a parent visiting, documenting, tagging, and geolocating a space, and this is all at the same time an act of care, curation, and unpaid infrastructural work. The visual clutter of the map suggests a kind of crowdsourced infrastructure of parenting and reflects a paradox: despite the apparent abundance of options, the labor required to find a truly child-friendly space remains ongoing and precarious.

@Adriana_ljubic. Map on Google Maps. Screenshot captured [12-07-2025] with permission. This image is for use only within this article and may not be reproduced or shared by third parties without the author’s prior permission.
We are drawn to the kidsproof-curating accounts in large part because of the format of the Instagram reel, a favored medium of the #kidsproof hashtag user. An Instagram reel is a short-form, vertical video format, designed for quick, engaging storytelling. Users record and edit videos up to 90 seconds and layer them with music, filters or text, and they are often an assemblage of still and moving images, all displayed for a few seconds.15Shirin Ghaffary, “Reels Is Facebook’s TikTok Clone and Its Future,” Vox, February 15, 2022, https://www.vox.com/recode/23002679/reels-facebook-tiktok-video. Reels are used to showcase places, experiences, and atmosphere: steaming coffee, close-ups of toys, ambient lighting, a beaming child digging their nose into a pink cupcake –  often overlaid with captions (‘do you see yourself here this weekend?’). Reels create a vibe: stitching together small fragments to convey more the mood of a space than an accurate documentation. This vibe then, takes precedence over the reality of the space – we are left with a vague notion of the place, a feeling of joy, and the desire to visit the space. One example is a reel that shows a young girl in a soft pink dress standing in a miniature kitchen set. She cradles a baby doll in a space echoing both domesticity and consumer aesthetics. The setting, an indoor play area within a café features a cottagecore design – gingham curtains, wood. Overlaid on the video the caption reads: “POV: You create a Google Maps map of cafés with play areas (indoor & outdoor) across the Netherlands & and now you always drink your coffee warm.” The text is funny and frames the mother as triumphant: she has done the digital labor of mapping child-friendly locations and is now rewarded with a peaceful coffee break. The image suggests empowerment, a mother reclaiming control in the city. At the same time, the scene also projects another ideal: quiet, aestheticized play that is carefully managed and contained. These moments of digital placemaking both open up the urban environment to caregivers and embed forms of middle-class consumption into public life.

@Adriana_ljubic, Screenshot of Instagram Reel, Instagram, April 8, 2024, screenshot captured [12-07-2025] with permission. This image is for use only within this article and may not be reproduced or shared by third parties without the author’s prior permission.
There is considerable diversity in the #kidsproof content on Instagram, and it is important to note that while this analysis focuses on cafés, restaurants and museums, not all accounts emphasize quiet play and messy, outdoor and exploratory activities are, of course, also represented. These fall into a different register of placemaking and represent the more unsupervised forms of play, tied to civic infrastructure. Other urban-adjacent venues, such as petting zoos or outdoor pancake houses with pet-alpacas occupy an intermediate space: they provide children with room to explore and play within commercialized settings that blend elements of public access with adult-oriented consumption. Indoor urban spaces like restaurants and cafés featured in reels, in contrast, are privately owned, monetized and their visual logic aligns with adult consumption. In the café, play is enabled but contained and stylized to match the branding of the space as well as the Instagram identity of the parent. The restaurant or café might have a play corner where the child is directed to, and ideally stays there for a while, aligning with urban middle-class ideals of order, safety, and consumption. In these corners, kids are typically presented with small toys such as coloring books, boxes of Lego or figurines. Specific toys promote specific play behaviors,16Salim Hashmi, “How Do Children Play with Toy Trains and for What Benefits? A Scoping Review,” European Journal of Investigation in Health, Psychology and Education 13, no. 10 (2023): 2112–34. and these toys here prompt children to stay in place. Nevin Dag et al. claim that play is “children’s only profession,” and fundamental to their cognitive, emotional, social development.17Nevin Dag, Emine Turkkan, Alper Kacar, and Huseyin Dag, “Children’s Only Profession: Playing with Toys,” North Clinical Istanbul 8, no. 4 (August 20, 2021): 414–20. Through play, children engage with and make sense of the world and cultivate skills such as critical learning and identity formation. I wonder what happens when play is confined to the boundaries of a play corner, and play becomes a regulated activity that limits the spontaneous, exploratory, and imaginative dimensions central to children’s development, but more so, I wonder what happens when this play becomes of a performative nature. Instagram posts do not just locate spaces where children can play, but they shape a particular vision of play itself. Perhaps today, we should not see the child in the city as being marginalized or erased, but rather, as strategically displayed: in social media reels, performing a type of play that is desirable for adults as it is curated, Instagrammable, and safe yet confined. Their environment is kid-proofed, and their presence is welcomed only insofar as it aligns with an aesthetic ideal of childhood. As Michel Foucault reminds us, discourse encompasses “practices that systematically form the objects of which they speak.”18Michel Foucault, The Archaeology of Knowledge and The Discourse on Language (Pantheon Books, 1972), 74. Might the performative nature and the creation of an Instagram-ready framing of play leave children confused about what play, or (and this is admittedly a stretch) even joy, actually is?

I wondered at the beginning of this article who is actually playing: the moms with their carefully curated Reel making, or the children? My contention is that free play is being restricted from several angles. First, cities have become increasingly less child-friendly, and urban planning has moved towards models that prioritize adult consumption. Within this design, mothers have stepped up, or rather, out of this design and have made attempts to take back the city and claim space for their children. By doing so through social media, however, this aestheticized content increasingly shapes what family leisure should look like. Moreover, as commercialized play spaces increasingly dominate social media feeds, city governments may even deprioritize investment in public playgrounds, parks, and grassroots play initiatives. The result might be that unrestricted play and public, free-of-cost play will disappear, as it is pushed into private kidproofed venues designed to meet adult expectations rather than children’s needs. A rather gloomy conclusion to this small interrogation, is that in the end, nobody seems to be really playing. What appears as play is, in fact, either performance or labor: while the child is unknowingly but strategically performing for his mom’s Instagram reels, shrinking the already limited spaces where free play is allowed in the city, the parent facilitates this through their unpaid labor pushing play into commercialized space, and Instagram might emerge as the ultimate beneficiary.

Notes

Notes
↑1, ↑2 “International Day of Play,” United Nations, accessed July 15, 2025, https://www.un.org/en/observances/international-day-of-play.
↑3 Roger Hart, “Containing Children: Some Lessons on Planning for Play from New York City,” Environment and Urbanization 14, no. 2 (2002): 135–48.
↑4 Tim Gill, Urban Playground: How Child-Friendly Planning and Design Can Save Cities (RIBA Publishing, 2021).
↑5 Willem R. Boterman, Residential Practices of Middle Classes in the Field of Parenthood (University of Amsterdam, 2012).
↑6 Gill, Urban Playground, 4.
↑7 Katherine L. Frohlich and Patricia A. Collins, “Children’s Right to the City and Their Independent Mobility: Why It Matters for Public Health,”  Epidemiol Community Health  78 (2024): 66–68; Roger Hart, “Containing Children: Some Lessons on Planning for Play from New York City,” Environment and Urbanization 14, no. 2 (2002): 135–48.
↑8 Frohlich and Collins, “Children’s Right to the City and Their Independent Mobility,” 66.
↑9 Michiel E. De Lange, “The Playful City: Using Play and Games to Foster Citizen Participation,” in Social Technologies and Collective Intelligence, ed. Aelita Skaržauskienė (Mykolas Romeris University, 2015), 428.
↑10 Michel de Certeau, “Spatial Stories,” in The Practice of Everyday Life, trans. Steven Rendall (University of California Press, 1984), 115–130.
↑11 Germaine R. Halegoua, The Digital City: Media and the Social Production of Place (NYU Press, 2020).
↑12 R. Reader, “Zuckerberg’s Enlisting the GOP against Tech Rivals Apple and Google,” Politico, April 20, 2025, https://www.politico.com/news/2025/04/20/zuckerbergs-enlisting-the-gop-against-tech-rivals-apple-and-google-00295945.
↑13 I built my corpus by doing regular, manual searches of the hashtag #kidsproof on Instagram between November 2024 and March 2025. From this process, I selected 50 public posts tagged with #kidsproof, shared between 2022 and 2025 by 13 distinct individual users. Posts were sampled to represent urban contexts: cafés, museums, and restaurants.
↑14 John D. Boy and Justus Uitermark, “Reassembling the City through Instagram,” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 42 (2017): 613.
↑15 Shirin Ghaffary, “Reels Is Facebook’s TikTok Clone and Its Future,” Vox, February 15, 2022, https://www.vox.com/recode/23002679/reels-facebook-tiktok-video.
↑16 Salim Hashmi, “How Do Children Play with Toy Trains and for What Benefits? A Scoping Review,” European Journal of Investigation in Health, Psychology and Education 13, no. 10 (2023): 2112–34.
↑17 Nevin Dag, Emine Turkkan, Alper Kacar, and Huseyin Dag, “Children’s Only Profession: Playing with Toys,” North Clinical Istanbul 8, no. 4 (August 20, 2021): 414–20.
↑18 Michel Foucault, The Archaeology of Knowledge and The Discourse on Language (Pantheon Books, 1972), 74.
Vermeeren, Laura. "Babyccinos and Reel Making: Who is Really Playing?" Mediapolis: A Journal of Cities and Culture 10, No. 3 (November 2025).
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.